This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. For more information, please visit my disclosure page.
You had to know that this was coming, right? No Harry Potter party would be complete without Polyjuice Potion! I’m sorry to say that you will not turn into a different person by drinking my version, unless of course you drink too much. But that would just be silly. You know what they always say…..everything in moderation!
I do have a bit of a confession to make, I did not know that lime sherbet contains milk! Silly me…so I could not actually drink this Polyjuice Potion. I suppose I was thinking sorbet, and didn’t realize that they are different things? Who knows.
It also looked much more ominous when I first made it…..
Versus the next day when I poured it back into the punch bowl to take the official photos, lol. I added more soda hoping to get that frothy, bubbly look again, but no such luck. 🙁
How to make a Polyjuice Potion Cocktail:
So the moral of this story is this. Add your lime sherbet to a large punch bowl. Pour in the vodka and lemon-lime soda…and serve immediately!
When the party is over, pour the remaining punch down the drain…..it will not keep in the refrigerator! 😉
If lime isn’t your thing, I also made Butter Beer Cocktails, and my favorite punch, Witches Brew Cocktail.
I bet you could even convince your friends that this Pumpkintini, is actually Pumpkin Juice!
*Update – different stores in different parts of the country sell varying shades of green sherbet, most are way too light. I have not been able to find any at all here in Arizona, which is why I have not remade this recipe yet to take new photos!
Enjoy!!
Polyjuice Potion Cocktail
Ingredients
- 1/2 Gallon lime sherbet
- 1 cup vodka optional
- 2 Liter bottle lemon-lime soda
Instructions
- Place lime sherbet into a large punch bowl or container.
- Pour in the vodka and soda, and serve.
Skip to content
You are so much fun. 🙂
I love this so much. Even though I am sorry to admit that I don’t like lime sherbet I have to say I would try it. If only to see if it would change me into you. haha
Pinned!
Oh my gosh–you’re hosting Harry Potter parties now? When am I invited? 😉 this is my absolute favorite idea–glad you left out Goyle’s toenails though! Great recipe!
Well this just sounds delicious! Too bad it can’t hold onto that ominous look…..but I’m sure it doesn’t last long anyway!
The ominous look lasts long enough for the party, so I guess that’s a good thing! 🙂
Love this! Harry Potter and crew wouldn’t mind the taste of this potion one bit SO creative. Can’t wait to feature this on Saturday Night Fever!
Vodka changes me into a different person, for certain. Pinned.
Oughto, that sounds like a fun story, lol. 🙂 Vodka puts me to sleep, rum makes me silly. You would think that it wouldn’t make a difference which type of alcohol, but it does!!
Love it!! Sounds tasty and looks so festive! Pinned
The ominous look wouldn’t stand a chance with my crew! Loving all of these recipes!
My daughter and her friends love Harry Potter…last Halloween they watched Harry Potter movies all night. Next time I just may make this for them, without the alcohol of course!
I made this at my Harry Potter party last night and it was AMAZING!! I added a lot more alcohol than you suggested and still couldn’t taste it lol – great drink!
I featured the Polyjuice potion recipe on my blog!! Thank you for the ideas, these were amazing this halloween. Definitely a big hit at my house warming party.
Our library made this (without vidka, lol) for the Harry Potter extravaganza and everyone loved it!